This research explored the experiences of children (age 9–10) when five Irish generalist primary teachers positioned meaningfulness as the priority filter for their pedagogical decision-making in physical education (n = 37). Pedagogies that support meaningfulness include those that are democratic and reflective, and give attention to individual experiences. Data sources included non-participant observations (n = 10), pupil diary (n = 101) and focus groups (n = 21 in five focus groups). Children’s experiences were enhanced by shared ownership of the learning focus, collaboration on learning activities and teacher’s attention to individual experiences. Results provide direction on a coherent approach to prioritising meaningfulness in primary physical education.