Murphy, Clíona (2008) The importance of teaching about the nature of science in the primary classroom. PhD thesis, Dublin City University.
Abstract
One o f the aims o f this research was to explore NoS conceptions amongst pre-service
and novice teachers and to establish the extent to which their pupils developed more
contemporary Nose conceptions, when taught about NoS through explicit means.
The study also considered the effects of explicitly teaching NoS on beginning
teachers' approaches to and perceptions o f teaching science and on their pupil's
reflections o f school science. A mixture of qualitative and quantitative
methodologies, which included questionnaires, group interviews and written
reflections, was utilised to explore the research questions.
There were four phases in the research. Phase one aimed at developing nineteen preservice
primary teachers' NoS conceptions. The extent to which these nineteen preservice
teachers planned and explicitly taught aspects o f NoS over the course of their
final teaching practice was addressed in the second phase. The third phase compared
the extent to which four beginning teachers planned for and explicitly addressed NoS
in their initial teaching year. Two o f these teachers had taken the NoS elective course
(test) the previous year and two had not (control). The third phase also explored the
effect that explicitly teaching NoS had on these beginning teachers' approaches to
and perceptions o f teaching science. The development o f N oS conceptions o f the
pupils o f these four beginning teachers (9-11 years) was also explored in the third
phase. The extent to which explicitly teaching NoS affected these primary children's
reflections on school science was also established in this phase. A preliminary
content analysis o f seven international curriculum documents and two international
assessment tools was conducted in the fourth phase to ascertain the extent to which
these docum ents explicitly assessed NoS.
The findings o f this study corroborated international research in that it indicated that
explicit methods of teaching about NoS resulted in the developm ent o f more
elaborate conceptions of NoS amongst pre-service prim ary teachers. However, the
findings also revealed that beginning primary teachers' contemporary NoS
conceptions could be transferred to their pupils utilising explicit hands-on reflective
approaches to teaching about NoS.
The study also revealed new insights that are relevant to the teaching of primary
science on a national and international basis. It was established that primary teachers
who em ployed explicit approaches to teaching NoS as part of the Science
Curriculum (DES, 1999a) utilised more hands-on, reflective constructivist
approaches to teaching science and appeared to be more enthusiastic and confident
about teaching science. In addition to developing more elaborate NoS conceptions
amongst prim ary children, this study also revealed that explicit approaches to NoS
resulted in an increased interest in and enjoyment o f school science amongst Irish
primary school children. The primary children in this study w ho experienced explicit
methods in NoS appeared to have been given more opportunities to employ and
develop their science skills than their peers who did not experience explicit
instruction in NoS. Other benefits of explicit approaches to teaching about NoS
apparent in the findings were improved language developm ent and an increase in the
children's ability to formulate and present argum ents for discussion. Opportunities
afforded to children when explicitly addressing NoS issues appear to have facilitated
them in the employment and development o f their reflective and thinking skills.
The research indicates that the development of contemporary conceptions of science
is an important aspect of primary science in that, amongst other benefits, it helps the
learning o f scientific concepts and skills and helps humanise science for children,
thus making it more interesting for them to learn. Pre-service and in-service courses
that provide teachers with the opportunity to develop their conceptual and
pedagogical knowledge o f NoS could facilitate Irish primary teachers in explicitly
teaching about NoS as part of the Science Curriculum (DES, 1999a).
There are concerns in Ireland regarding the decline in the num ber o f students taking
science at secondary and tertiary level (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development (OECD), 2002b). The report o f the Task Force on the Physical
Sciences (2002) included a number of recommendations in relation to science at
primary level, which included improving the quality o f science teaching, in-career
developm ent for teachers and the establishment o f an integrated national science
awareness programme. This study revealed that incorporating explicit approaches to
NoS as part o f the Science Curriculum increased teachers' and pupils' interest in and
enjoyment o f science. If the development o f NoS was included as a core aim in the
Primary Science Curriculum, primary children could become more interested in
science, which may in turn lead to an increase in the uptake o f science beyond the
point o f choice.
Metadata
Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
---|---|
Date of Award: | November 2008 |
Refereed: | No |
Supervisor(s): | Kilfeather, Paula, Beggs, Jim and Murphy, Colette |
Subjects: | Social Sciences > Education Social Sciences > Teaching |
DCU Faculties and Centres: | DCU Faculties and Schools > Institute of Education > School of STEM Education, Innovation, & Global Studies |
Use License: | This item is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. View License |
ID Code: | 22535 |
Deposited On: | 03 Aug 2018 15:31 by Thomas Murtagh . Last Modified 10 Sep 2021 10:11 |
Documents
Full text available as:
Preview |
PDF
- Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
14MB |
Downloads
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Archive Staff Only: edit this record